The table below lists review assignments. Each team is responsible for the timely submission of a draft report to the team they are reviewed by. Here are the ground rules:

• Your team will be graded based on the review that it writes, not on the review that it gets, so the review is strictly to your benefit, since it may point out weaknesses that you can correct before the final evaluation.
• A good review will do the following:
  • Recognize the organization and approach of the study, and identify and analyze the strengths and weaknesses.
  • Make concrete and practical recommendations for improvement.

• The review should be no longer than two single-spaced pages, and should be written as a joint team effort.

Review assignments

Amanda Swanekamp, Aja Bulla-Richards	reviewed by	Jeremy Chinnis, Megan Driscoll
Jeremy Chinnis, Megan Driscoll	reviewed by	Amanda Swanekamp, Aja Bulla-Richards
Emily Miyares, Jillian Wahl	reviewed by	Joel Trantham, Randall Winston
Joel Trantham, Randall Winston	reviewed by	Emily Miyares, Jillian Wahl
Kurt Marsh, Debbie Ku	reviewed by	Jonathan Coble, Justin Hershberger
Jonathan Coble, Justin Hershberger	reviewed by	Kurt Marsh, Debbie Ku
Lin Jia, Tina Cheng	reviewed by	Daniel Larossa, Erin Root
Daniel Larossa, Erin Root	reviewed by	Lin Jia, Tina Cheng
Haojun Zhan, Chase Sparling-Beckley	reviewed by	Jie Huang, Michael Levy
Jie Huang, Michael Levy	reviewed by	Haojun Zhan, Chase Sparling-Beckley
Sarah Turner, Feng Wang	reviewed by	Jason Layel, Robert Edsall
Amadeo Bennetta, Daphne Lasky	reviewed by	Sarah Turner, Feng Wang
Jason Layel, Robert Edsall	reviewed by	Amadeo Bennetta, Daphne Lasky

Schedule:

Mon Nov 9	During the lab meeting, give a copy of your draft to the team that is assigned to review it.
Mon Nov 16	At the beginning of lab, submit copies of your review and the reviewed paper both to me and to the team that wrote the paper, so you'll need two copies of both the reviewed report and the review. The lab meeting will be devoted to face-to-face meetings among the review groups to discuss the drafts and how to improve them.